The Room Behind the Relationship: An Ecological Ethics from the Perspective of a Trainee Counsellor

More Realms banner reading The Room Behind the Relationship: An Ecological Ethics from the Perspective of a Trainee Counsellor, beside a photo of a red chair and a yellow chair facing each other across a small table under a tall sunlit window

There is a question I keep returning to as I train in the counselling professions, and it has very little to do with technique. It is this: when something goes wrong between a practitioner and the person in front of them, where does the fault actually live? Professional ethics codes tend to answer that question by looking at exactly two people. One is trusted with power, the other is owed care, and the code exists to hold the first accountable to the second. It is a good frame as far as it goes. But I have started to wonder what it leaves out, and what gets quietly absorbed by the client when it does.

What Ethics Asks Of Us

Ethics, in the simplest sense, are the moral principles that guide right and wrong conduct (Bond, 2015). In the helping professions they exist because there is rarely one correct answer to a difficult situation, only a considered judgement, reached in the open rather than alone. The British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy’s new Ethical Framework, which becomes mandatory for members in November 2026, names twelve principles that practitioners hold together rather than apply one at a time: confidentiality, honesty, transparency, doing no harm, acting in the client’s best interest, respect, fairness, anti-oppression, trust, collaboration, compassion and integrity (BACP, 2026). Read as a set, they describe a good relationship more than a checklist: attention to power, to truthfulness, to a client’s own right to decide, and, in anti-oppression, an explicit instruction to stay aware of the power moving between people in a room.

What strikes me about the framework is its shift towards relationships and responsibilities, and away from rules alone. That feels ecological to me: ethics as something that happens between people, cultures and systems, rather than inside one person. It says explicitly that ethical practice is something built between two people who are both changed by the encounter, rather than a fixed code applied to a passive client.

And yet even a framework this relational still assumes the relationship is the whole story. It asks what passed between the practitioner and the person who came to them. It does not ask, in any sustained way, what else was in the room.

Assemblage, Not Character

When I sit with a dilemma from practice, the question that actually helps me is rarely “what is wrong with this person?” It is closer to asking what assemblage of people, spaces, training and systems produced the difficulty in front of me. An assemblage, in Deleuze and Guattari’s (1987) sense, is a temporary gathering of unlike things, bodies and buildings and timetables and funding streams, that arrange themselves into an outcome nobody alone chose. Difficulty is rarely produced by one person’s character. It is produced by an arrangement, and arrangements can be redesigned in a way that a person’s character cannot be legislated into changing.

I think of this as closer to a rhizome than a rulebook, with small connections such as supervision, honesty and reflection growing sideways rather than descending from a single root of correct conduct (Deleuze & Guattari, 1987). Consent becomes an ongoing relation rather than a form signed once. A sudden ending becomes a network of care that keeps growing new connections even when one node has to leave, rather than a single failure to be blamed on the person who could not stay. None of this excuses harm. It relocates where we go looking for its cause, and it asks us to keep looking somewhere other than inward, at the client, when things go wrong.

The Room We Forgot

This is where a piece I have been building with Ryan Boren for Star Stuff, our joint project between Stimpunks Foundation and More Realms, has been doing real work in my thinking. In “Six Principles and a Room” (Star Stuff, 2026), we looked closely at how little vocabulary professional ethics codes actually have for the material world a client walks in from. Fluorescent lighting, chaotic transitions, a waiting list, a funding incentive that shapes how long a session can run: none of these can be struck off a professional register, so none of them appear in a code built for exactly two parties. When the only parties to an ethic are two people, everything that is not one of those two people has to be recorded somewhere else, and the only somewhere else on offer is inside the person who came in. Distress produced by an unaccommodating environment gets written up as though it originated in the individual, which quietly reinforces the very deficit thinking the helping professions say they want to move away from.

Félix Guattari’s framework of three ecologies gives this a useful shape: the mental ecology of how we relate to ourselves, the social ecology of how we relate to each other, and the environmental ecology of the material conditions that enable or constrain those relations in the first place (Guattari, 2000). A two-person ethic, however carefully it is written, only ever reaches the first ecology and, at its most relational, gestures toward the second. The third, the room itself, tends to enter the code only as a reason a practitioner could not do the ethical thing, a line to write in a file explaining an exemption, rather than something the profession takes responsibility for shaping.

Star Stuff (2026) also draws on Ombre Tarragnat’s concept of ethodiversity, which extends the logic of neurodiversity to the many ways of sensing, moving, attending and relating that exist across people and systems (Tarragnat, 2025), and on Mia Mingus’s idea of access intimacy, the felt sense of not having to explain your access needs because the space was already built with you in mind (Mingus, 2011). Put together, they describe a practice I think of as ethodivergent hearth building: making spaces that sustain difference through sensory consideration, co-regulation, bodily autonomy and relational consent, rather than spaces that merely tolerate difference once it has already caused someone distress (Star Stuff, 2026). None of this dissolves accountability into vague talk of systems. Star Stuff is careful on this point: there is exactly one disqualifier at the door, and it is harm rather than difference (Star Stuff, 2026). Widening the ethic beyond two people does not soften who is answerable. It names more of the people who actually are.

Whose Voice Counts as a Voice

The twelve principles do real work around respect, fairness and anti-oppression, but they are still written for one default mode of exchange: two people, speaking, usually face to face. Intersectionality is useful here because it names exactly the move the framework has not yet made. Oppression and access needs do not stack neatly on top of each other but multiply through the specific person in front of you, so that race, gender, disability, class and language are never separable strands but a single lived position (Crenshaw, 1989, 1991). A framework that reaches anti-oppression as an abstract principle while staying silent on how someone communicates has, in practice, still built its ethics around whoever can most easily fit the existing room.

Neurodivergence sharpens this further. The double empathy problem reframes communication difficulty between Autistic and non-Autistic people as a mutual, two-way mismatch rather than a deficit sitting inside the Autistic person alone (Milton, 2012). Carried into a counselling relationship, a practitioner’s discomfort with an unfamiliar way of communicating is data about a mismatch the practitioner is also inside of, rather than neutral information about the client. Fairness, as currently written, asks for equal treatment. It does not yet ask what equal treatment requires when the two people in the room do not share a communication register to begin with.

Non-speaking and AAC-using clients make the gap concrete. A framework that never once names communication modality has, by omission, defaulted to spoken language as the medium ethics happens in. Presuming competence, offering AAC-compatible options, and building in the time unhurried communication needs are part of ethical practice itself, rather than accommodations added on afterwards. They are what respect and best interest actually require once a client’s voice does not arrive by mouth, and once the device, board or spelling method carrying that voice is understood as part of the relationship rather than a workaround for it, closer to Barad’s sense of mattering, where the tool and the meaning it carries are entangled rather than separable (Barad, 2007).

The same logic extends to modality more broadly. Online and text-based counselling is sometimes framed as a lesser substitute for real, in-person work, but for an Autistic client who processes written language more easily than live speech, or for anyone whom travel or a shared physical room puts out of reach, that access is the condition under which the relationship becomes possible at all. Access intimacy names the difference precisely: the felt sense of not having to explain, translate or justify an access need because the space was already built with it in mind (Mingus, 2011). A framework silent on modality leaves every client who does not fit the speaking, in-person default doing that explaining themselves, session after session.

None of this dissolves into anything goes. It sits inside the same floor the whole piece keeps returning to, that the one disqualifier is harm rather than difference (Star Stuff, 2026). Widening what counts as a voice, and what counts as a room built to receive it, does not lower the standard of care. It is what meeting that standard actually looks like once “the client” stops meaning one default kind of person.

Toward an Ecology of Practice

What would it mean to bring the room into the helping professions’ own account of ethics, rather than leaving it as a private reflection practitioners do off the record? Supervision starts to look less like a confessional, where a practitioner discloses a personal limit or bias to be corrected, and more like an ecological practice, a place where the whole arrangement (the person, the room, the training, the referral pathway, the funding) can be examined together. Self-awareness stops being only about a practitioner’s own reactions and becomes a habit of asking what conditions produced this reaction in this room, on this day, with this level of support available. Transparency extends outward from “here is what I can offer you” to something closer to “here is the arrangement you have walked into, and here is what in it was not built with you in mind.”

I do not think this replaces the relational focus the profession has been moving toward. I think it completes it. A practitioner and a client are never only two people in a room. They are two people inside a room, and the room has already been doing quite a lot of the talking before either of them says a word.

Reflection

Maybe the pattern I am reaching for is something closer to a rhizome than a rulebook, or to star stuff scattered and slowly finding each other again: small connections such as supervision, honesty and a willingness to name the room, growing sideways into a practice that stays answerable to each new relationship as it forms, rather than one that keeps quietly finding the fault in the person who walked in already carrying enough.

Appendix: The Core Responsibilities

Alongside the twelve principles, the framework sets out core responsibilities: the practical duties without which no professional service can be considered safe, trustworthy or respectful (BACP, 2026). They are organised under four headings.

1. Build appropriate relationships. 1.1 Treat people with respect. 1.2 Give people the information they need to make choices about their work with us. 1.3 Establish and maintain appropriate professional and personal boundaries. 1.4 Work collaboratively to resolve ethical dilemmas or challenges.

2. Keep ourselves, colleagues and those using our services safe. 2.1 Take account of our own personal safety and the safety of those we work with. 2.2 Be honest and transparent with those who use our services about anything that has not gone to plan in our work together. 2.3 Maintain our health and wellbeing. 2.4 Act appropriately to protect people from harm.

3. Understand and act on our legal and professional responsibilities. 3.1 Protect the confidentiality and privacy of those accessing our services. 3.2 Keep appropriate records. 3.3 Act on our responsibilities in reporting serious crime and safeguarding concerns. 3.4 Be financially responsible.

4. Deliver services to high professional standards. 4.1 We must be competent to deliver the services we offer. 4.2 Have adequate insurance. 4.3 Have adequate supervision that enables us to reflect in depth about all aspects of our practice. 4.4 Treat people fairly. 4.5 Manage breaks, endings in ways that minimise the impact for clients and service users.

Read this way, the four headings already reach further than a two-person frame, even before Star Stuff’s critique is laid alongside them. Building relationships, staying safe, meeting legal responsibilities and delivering to a standard are not things one person does alone in a room with another. They depend on supervision existing and being resourced, on records systems that protect privacy, and on insurance and financial structures that hold a practice up at all. The room a two-person ethic forgets is, in a sense, already named here, just named as context for individual duty rather than as something the profession takes responsibility for building well.

References

Barad, K. (2007). Meeting the universe halfway: Quantum physics and the entanglement of matter and meaning. Duke University Press.

Bond, T. (2015). Standards and ethics for counselling in action (4th ed.). Sage.

British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy. (2026). Ethical framework for the counselling professions. BACP. https://www.bacp.co.uk/events-and-resources/ethics-and-standards/ethical-framework-for-the-counselling-professions/

Crenshaw, K. (1989). Demarginalizing the intersection of race and sex: A Black feminist critique of antidiscrimination doctrine, feminist theory and antiracist politics. University of Chicago Legal Forum, 1989(1), 139–167.

Crenshaw, K. (1991). Mapping the margins: Intersectionality, identity politics, and violence against women of color. Stanford Law Review, 43(6), 1241–1299.

Deleuze, G., & Guattari, F. (1987). A thousand plateaus: Capitalism and schizophrenia (B. Massumi, Trans.). University of Minnesota Press. (Original work published 1980)

Guattari, F. (2000). The three ecologies (I. Pindar & P. Sutton, Trans.). Athlone Press. (Original work published 1989)

Milton, D. E. M. (2012). On the ontological status of autism: The “double empathy problem”. Disability & Society, 27(6), 883–887. https://doi.org/10.1080/09687599.2012.710008

Mingus, M. (2011, May 5). Access intimacy: The missing link. Leaving Evidence. https://leavingevidence.wordpress.com/2011/05/05/access-intimacy-the-missing-link/

Star Stuff. (2026). Six principles and a room. Stimpunks Foundation × More Realms. https://starstuff.earth/six-principles-and-a-room.html

Tarragnat, O. (2025, February 25). What is ethodiversity? https://ombretarragnat.com/2025/02/25/what-is-ethodiversity/