Tag: Sylvia Plath

  • Sylvia Plath and the Violence of Normativity

    Sylvia Plath and the Violence of Normativity

    Content note: this piece discusses suicide, psychiatric treatment including electroconvulsive therapy, and mental distress. If you are struggling, please reach out. In the UK and Ireland you can contact Samaritans any time on 116 123.

    A neuro-affirming, Mad Pride reading of The Bell Jar

    I have been reading Sylvia Plath since I was a teenager. Long before I had the language of monotropism, and long before I knew I was Autistic, Plath was already there, at the centre of one of those all-consuming interests that I didn’t yet understand. I have ring binders full of articles printed on that dot-matrix paper with the holes along the sides, three shelves of books, and decades of returning to the same pages. I couldn’t have told you then why I needed her so completely, but I think I can now. She was writing about what it feels like to be a mind that doesn’t fit the shape the world expects it to take, and about the quiet, everyday violence of being pressed into that shape anyway. That pressure, the violence of normativity, is what this piece is about.

    I want to be clear from the start that this is a reading of Esther Greenwood, and of my own recognition of her, rather than an attempt to diagnose Sylvia Plath. Plath was a real person who cannot speak for herself here, and the novel, although it draws closely on her own experiences in 1953, is still a novel. What I can do is read Esther through the frameworks that have helped me understand my own life, and notice what they open up.

    The Bell Jar was first published in January 1963 under the pseudonym Victoria Lucas (Plath, 1963). A month later, Plath died by suicide. The novel itself follows Esther through a breakdown, a suicide attempt and her time in psychiatric hospitals, and any honest reading has to hold that weight. It is usually framed as a story about mental illness, and Plath herself is so often framed as tragic, a cautionary tale about a brilliant woman destroyed by her own mind. From a Mad Pride perspective I find that framing uncomfortable. It places all of the suffering inside the person and very little of it in the world that refused to make room for her, and I think it also makes it harder to see how much of Esther’s despair is a response to the life she is being asked to fit into.

    Mad Studies and Mad Pride hold that distress is real, and that it can be devastating, while also refusing to treat madness only as something broken inside an individual (LeFrançois et al., 2013). That matters here, because there is a trap in neurodivergent readings of Esther. It would be easy to say that she was “really” Autistic and therefore not mad, as though being mad were the worse thing to be, and that kind of rescue quietly repeats the sanism Mad Pride pushes against. I don’t want to rescue Esther from madness. I want to read her as possibly neurodivergent and Mad, and to ask, with Nick Walker’s (2021) neuroqueer theory, what happens to a mind like hers when it is expected to perform neurotypicality, femininity and productivity all at once, without any language or community to help it understand itself.

    The fig tree and the monotropic mind

    One of the most famous passages in The Bell Jar is the fig tree. Esther imagines her life branching out in front of her, each fig a different future, a husband and children, a famous poet, a brilliant professor, an editor, travels abroad, and she pictures herself sitting in the crotch of the tree, “starving to death, just because I couldn’t make up my mind” (Plath, 1963, Chapter 7), while the figs wrinkle and fall. The passage is usually read as depression, ambivalence or the narrow choices offered to women in the 1950s, and it is all of those things. When I read it through monotropism, though, I see something more.

    Monotropism, the theory developed by Dinah Murray, Mike Lesser and Wenn Lawson (Murray et al., 2005), and carried forward today through the work of Fergus Murray and the wider community, describes how many Autistic people tend to concentrate their attention in a small number of deep, intense channels rather than spreading it lightly across many things at once. Tanya Adkin’s (2022) idea of monotropic split describes what happens when a monotropic person is pulled between competing demands and has to divide attention that naturally wants to flow in one direction, and how exhausting and destabilising that can be.

    I wrote about monotropic split in my reading of Wuthering Heights, where Cathy is torn between Heathcliff and Edgar Linton, and I see something similar in Esther. Each fig is not a light option to be weighed and set aside. Each one is a whole life, real and total and consuming, and to choose one means tearing attention away from all the others. Esther’s paralysis reads to me less like a lack of will and more like a monotropic mind meeting a decision structure built for a different kind of mind, and then being judged as failing when she cannot show the expected flexibility. I recognised that feeling at fifteen without having any name for it, and I have the name for it now.

    The body under pressure

    Troberg (2025), in a neuroqueer close reading written as a degree project, finds signs of Autistic traits throughout Esther’s narration, as well as traces of what she describes as an Autistic writing style. Reading alongside her, I notice Esther’s intense sensory responses to the city, her complicated relationship with food, her constant effort to perform the version of herself that others expect, and the way her capacity gradually collapses until she can no longer sleep, read or write. To me, that collapse reads very much like the Autistic burnout so many of us know, where the things that once came easily simply stop being possible.

    The image at the heart of the novel captures this too. Esther feels that wherever she went she would be “sitting under the same glass bell jar, stewing in my own sour air” (Plath, 1963, Chapter 15). Being sealed off and watching life through glass is something I hear Autistic people describe again and again in our community spaces, and it is something I recognise in my own experience of burnout. Khatun (2026) brings crip theory and neurodiversity to the same text and argues that Esther’s distress is a response to a society built around narrow ideas of normality, not a biological defect. Drawing on Robert McRuer’s idea of compulsory able-bodiedness, she shows how the demand that Esther be emotionally stable, productive, academically exceptional and appropriately feminine pushes her towards breakdown. In this reading, the glass of the bell jar is made, at least in part, of other people’s expectations.

    The erasure of women

    The novel is set in 1953. At that time autism was understood, where it was understood at all, as a rare childhood condition, closely tied to ideas of childhood schizophrenia, and the categories open to a distressed young woman like Esther were depression, schizophrenia and the long, gendered history of the “female malady” (Showalter, 1985). As I wrote in my piece on Grunya Sukhareva, Sukhareva had already described Autistic girls in 1927, yet that knowledge never reached the people deciding what was wrong with women like Esther. For decades afterwards, women whose traits we might now recognise as Autistic or ADHD were more likely to be diagnosed with depression, personality disorders, bipolar disorder or eating disorders (Hendrickx, 2015; Troberg, 2025). The pattern continues today. A recent Dutch study found that one in three Autistic women reported at least one earlier psychiatric diagnosis that they felt was a misdiagnosis, compared with around one in six Autistic men (Kentrou et al., 2024).

    I think intersectionality sits at the heart of Esther’s story. Being a woman, being neurodivergent and being non-normative in your emotional, sensory and social life do not simply add together as separate difficulties. They compound each other and make each other harder to see. The psychiatric system Esther meets has one story available to it, breakdown, treatment, recovery and compliance, and it applies that story to a brilliant, non-conforming young woman who may be masking neurodivergence, resisting the gender roles offered to her and living with real sensory and processing differences all at the same time. This is why the neuroqueer frame feels so important to me. Walker (2021) refuses to separate the politics of gender, sexuality and neurodivergence, because they are entangled systems of normalisation, and pushing against one always involves the others. I have explored where those systems come from in Wyrd, Weird, and the Invention of Normal and The Neuronormative Paradigm.

    Psychiatric power and the meaning of recovery

    Esther’s first electroconvulsive therapy, given by Dr Gordon after only the briefest conversation with her and with her mother, is one of the most disturbing scenes I have ever read, and Esther experiences it as a punishment. Later, under the care of Dr Nolan, who listens to her and treats her with far more warmth and honesty, the treatment is presented very differently, and Esther feels the bell jar lift (Khatun, 2026; Plath, 1963). I want to hold that complexity honestly, because the novel does not offer a simple story about psychiatry, and for some people psychiatric care is part of how they stay alive. Even so, from a Mad Pride perspective, I notice how much of Esther’s treatment is aimed at making her legible and manageable again, able to function within the social order without disturbing it, rather than helping her to flourish as the person she actually is.

    Recovery in the dominant psychiatric model so often means a return to productivity and social conformity, and for a neurodivergent person that can mean returning to the very conditions that caused the crisis. Esther’s recovery at the end of the novel is uncertain. She is functioning again, but she wonders how she can know that someday “the bell jar, with its stifling distortions, wouldn’t descend again” (Plath, 1963, Chapter 20). Knowing what happened to Plath only weeks after the book was published, I find that line almost unbearable to read. To me it sounds less like the language of cure and more like the voice of someone who has learned to survive a world that was not built for her, while nothing about that world has changed.

    Testimony and recognition

    I read The Bell Jar as testimony, a record of what it costs to be a particular kind of person in a particular kind of world. When Autistic and Mad people, in online spaces, in academic readings and in the quiet recognition of those of us who have read Plath since our teens, find ourselves in her work, I think what we are doing is closer to recognition than to romanticising. For so many of us, finding ourselves in fiction is how we first begin to understand who we are. Before diagnosis, before community and before language, there can be the strange shock of reading your own inner life in someone else’s words. Before I knew I was AuDHD I knew I was the person who couldn’t choose between the figs.

    Mad Pride asks us to hold two things together: the very real suffering that comes from living in a world not built for your mind, and the refusal to locate the whole problem in the mind itself. For me, Esther Greenwood shows what happens when a neurodivergent and Mad young woman is offered no supportive framework, no community and no accommodation, only the demand to perform normality and the consequences when she cannot. That is the violence of normativity. I have come to think that the bell jar was never only Esther’s. It is also the neurotypical, patriarchal social order, sealed and airless, that so many of us have spent our lives pressing our hands against from the inside, and I hope that naming it together makes the glass a little thinner so we can breathe a bit more.

    If this piece has stirred up difficult feelings, please be gentle with yourself and reach out to someone you trust. In the UK and Ireland, Samaritans are available any time on 116 123 or at samaritans.org.

    References

    Adkin, T. (2022, July 14). What is monotropic split? NeuroHub Connect. https://neurohubcommunity.org/2022/07/14/guest-post-what-is-monotropic-split/

    Hendrickx, S. (2015). Women and girls with autism spectrum disorder: Understanding life experiences from early childhood to old age. Jessica Kingsley Publishers.

    Kentrou, V., Livingston, L. A., Grove, R., Hoekstra, R. A., & Begeer, S. (2024). Perceived misdiagnosis of psychiatric conditions in autistic adults. eClinicalMedicine, 71, Article 102586. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.eclinm.2024.102586

    Khatun, F. (2026). Ableism and psychic distress: Rethinking neurodiversity and disability in The Bell Jar. Literariness Journal, 1(2), 1622–1632. https://literarinessjournal.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/04/Khatun-Farhina-Ableism-and-Psychic-Distress-Rethinking-Neurodiversity-and-Disability-in-The-Bell-Jar.pdf

    LeFrançois, B. A., Menzies, R., & Reaume, G. (Eds.). (2013). Mad matters: A critical reader in Canadian mad studies. Canadian Scholars’ Press.

    Murray, D., Lesser, M., & Lawson, W. (2005). Attention, monotropism and the diagnostic criteria for autism. Autism, 9(2), 139–156. https://doi.org/10.1177/1362361305051398

    Plath, S. [Lucas, V.]. (1963). The bell jar. Heinemann.

    Showalter, E. (1985). The female malady: Women, madness, and English culture, 1830–1980. Pantheon Books.

    Troberg, G. (2025). Not a madwoman: A neuroqueer reading of Sylvia Plath’s The Bell Jar [Bachelor’s thesis, University of Gothenburg]. GUPEA. https://hdl.handle.net/2077/88399

    Walker, N. (2021). Neuroqueer heresies: Notes on the neurodiversity paradigm, autistic empowerment, and postnormal possibilities. Autonomous Press.